{"status":"ok","message-type":"work","message-version":"1.0.0","message":{"indexed":{"date-parts":[[2026,5,4]],"date-time":"2026-05-04T14:15:08Z","timestamp":1777904108700,"version":"3.51.4"},"reference-count":124,"publisher":"SAGE Publications","issue":"4","license":[{"start":{"date-parts":[[2004,11,1]],"date-time":"2004-11-01T00:00:00Z","timestamp":1099267200000},"content-version":"tdm","delay-in-days":0,"URL":"https:\/\/journals.sagepub.com\/page\/policies\/text-and-data-mining-license"}],"content-domain":{"domain":[],"crossmark-restriction":false},"short-container-title":["Linacre Q"],"published-print":{"date-parts":[[2004,11]]},"DOI":"10.1080\/20508549.2004.11877727","type":"journal-article","created":{"date-parts":[[2017,6,1]],"date-time":"2017-06-01T08:13:55Z","timestamp":1496304835000},"page":"281-307","source":"Crossref","is-referenced-by-count":0,"title":["Reaffirming Human Dignity in Disputes over Children Born from Assisted Reproductive Technologies"],"prefix":"10.1177","volume":"71","author":[{"given":"Adam E.","family":"Frey","sequence":"first","affiliation":[{"name":"Ave Maria School of Law."}],"role":[{"role":"author","vocabulary":"crossref"}]}],"member":"179","published-online":{"date-parts":[[2004,11,1]]},"reference":[{"key":"bibr1-20508549.2004.11877727","unstructured":"79 Cat. Rptr. 2d 280 (Cal. Ct. App. 1998)"},{"key":"bibr2-20508549.2004.11877727","first-page":"25","volume":"26","author":"O'Hara Milena D.","year":"1998","journal-title":"W.St. U.L Rev."},{"key":"bibr3-20508549.2004.11877727","unstructured":"Id. at 26-27. O'Hara & Vorzimer claim to have successfully represented a gay couple in obtaining a judgment or paternity under\n                      Buzzanca.\n                      Id. at 36-37."},{"key":"bibr4-20508549.2004.11877727","first-page":"127","volume":"33","author":"Hurwitz Ilana","year":"2000","journal-title":"Conn. L. Rev."},{"key":"bibr5-20508549.2004.11877727","unstructured":"Johnson v. Calvert, 851 P.2d 776, 796-97 (1993) (Kennedy. J., dissenting)."},{"key":"bibr6-20508549.2004.11877727","unstructured":"In re Marriage of Moschetta, 30\n                      Cal. Rptr\n                      , 2d 893, 894 (Cal. Ct. App. 1994)."},{"key":"bibr7-20508549.2004.11877727","first-page":"567","volume":"77","author":"Campbell Ardis L.","year":"2001","journal-title":"A.L.R."},{"key":"bibr8-20508549.2004.11877727","first-page":"295","volume":"83","author":"Yaworsky Michael J.","year":"2001","journal-title":"A.L.R."},{"key":"bibr9-20508549.2004.11877727","unstructured":"In re Baby M., 537 A.2d 1226, 1235 (1988)."},{"key":"bibr10-20508549.2004.11877727","unstructured":"Belisto v. Clark, 67 Ohio Misc. 2d 54, 63 (Ohio Ct. Common Pleas 1994). Note that some \u201cintent\u201d theories, infra Part IV, argue that ART births are not adoption, but that the \u201cintended\u201d parent\n                      is\n                      the natural parent and therefore the child is surrendered to its rightful parents."},{"key":"bibr11-20508549.2004.11877727","unstructured":"A recent survey of U.S. surrogacy law is available at Campbell, supra n. 13."},{"key":"bibr12-20508549.2004.11877727","unstructured":"The Declaration of Independence para. 1 (U.S. 1776). The word \u201cdignity\u201d itself does not appear, but the document's phrase \u201call Men are created equal, that they are endowed by their Creator with certain inalienable Rights, that among these are Life. Liberty, and the Pursuit of Happiness\u201d captures the essential concept."},{"key":"bibr13-20508549.2004.11877727","unstructured":"United Nations Charter Preamble. The U.N. commits itself \u201cto reaffirm faith in fundamental human rights, in the dignity and worth of the human person, in the equal rights of men and women of nations large and small.\u201d"},{"key":"bibr14-20508549.2004.11877727","unstructured":"Article 1 of the Declaration recognizes that \u201c[a]ll human beings are born free and equal in dignity and human rights.\u201d Additionally. Article 4 prohibits human slavery, and Article 7 holds all human persons equal before the law in light of equal protection."},{"key":"bibr15-20508549.2004.11877727","doi-asserted-by":"crossref","unstructured":"Oscar Schachter, Comment: \u201cHuman Dignity as a Normative Concept.\u201d 77\n                      A.J.I.L.\n                      , 848, 849 (1983).","DOI":"10.2307\/2202536"},{"key":"bibr16-20508549.2004.11877727","unstructured":"Catechism of the Catholic Church\n                      (\u201cCCC\u201d), \u00a7 1930."},{"key":"bibr17-20508549.2004.11877727","unstructured":"Nicholas Tonti-Fillippini. \u201cThe Concept of Human Dignity in the International Rights Instruments,\u201d in\n                      The Identity and Status of the Human Embryo; Proceedings of the Third Assembly of the Pontifical Academy for Life\n                      , 388, 390 (Juan De Dios Vial Correa & Elio Sgreccia eds., Libreria Editrice Vaticana, 1999)."},{"key":"bibr18-20508549.2004.11877727","unstructured":"Schachter supra n. 21, at 849."},{"issue":"37","key":"bibr19-20508549.2004.11877727","author":"Paul John","year":"1988","journal-title":"Christifiedeles Laici (On the Vocation and the Mission of the Lay Faithful in the Church and in the World)"},{"key":"bibr20-20508549.2004.11877727","unstructured":"Id. at 851."},{"key":"bibr21-20508549.2004.11877727","unstructured":"Tonti-Fillipini, supra n. 18, at 386."},{"key":"bibr22-20508549.2004.11877727","unstructured":"Id."},{"key":"bibr23-20508549.2004.11877727","unstructured":"JohnsonSara L. LL.B., Annotation. \u201cParent and Child\u201d \u00a7 9, 59\n                      Am Jur\n                      2d 141."},{"key":"bibr24-20508549.2004.11877727","unstructured":"Id. at 136."},{"key":"bibr25-20508549.2004.11877727","unstructured":"Id. at 143."},{"key":"bibr26-20508549.2004.11877727","author":"Paul John","journal-title":"Evangeliium Vitae"},{"key":"bibr27-20508549.2004.11877727","author":"Paul John","year":"1993","journal-title":"Veritatis Splendor"},{"key":"bibr28-20508549.2004.11877727","author":"Paul John","year":"1991","journal-title":"Centesimus Annus"},{"key":"bibr29-20508549.2004.11877727","unstructured":"CCC, supra n. 22. \u00a7 2378."},{"key":"bibr30-20508549.2004.11877727","unstructured":"Centesimus Annus\n                      , supra n. 29, at 47.1."},{"key":"bibr31-20508549.2004.11877727","unstructured":"LangstonJames Lesbians: We Made Our Baby Deaf on Purpose, available at http:\/\/www.thislondon.com\/dynamic\/news\/story.himl?in_review_id=545846&in_review_text)id=5l1810."},{"key":"bibr32-20508549.2004.11877727","unstructured":"Id."},{"key":"bibr33-20508549.2004.11877727","unstructured":"Id."},{"key":"#cr-split#-bibr34-20508549.2004.11877727.1","unstructured":"The Catholic Church does support technologies which assist married couples in conjugal procreation, so long as the science does not violate human dignity. See Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith. Instruction on Bioethics (Donum Vitae) (1987), II, B, 8"},{"key":"#cr-split#-bibr34-20508549.2004.11877727.2","unstructured":"RiceCharles E. 50 Questions on the Natural Low: What It Is and Why We Need It (Ignatius Press, 1993) 381."},{"key":"bibr35-20508549.2004.11877727","unstructured":"CCC, supra n. 22. \u00a7 2376, citing\n                      Instruction on Bioethics\n                      II, 1"},{"key":"bibr36-20508549.2004.11877727","unstructured":"Id. \u00a7 2377, citing\n                      Instruction on Bioethics\n                      II, 5."},{"key":"bibr37-20508549.2004.11877727","author":"Paul John","year":"1991","journal-title":"Address"},{"key":"bibr38-20508549.2004.11877727","unstructured":"CCC, supra n. 22 \u00a7 2363."},{"key":"bibr39-20508549.2004.11877727","unstructured":"Instruction on Bioethics\n                      , supra n.40, I, 6."},{"key":"bibr40-20508549.2004.11877727","unstructured":"Id."},{"key":"bibr41-20508549.2004.11877727","first-page":"253","author":"Rice Charles E.","year":"1999","journal-title":"The Winning Side: Questions on Winning the Culture of Life"},{"key":"bibr42-20508549.2004.11877727","unstructured":"CCC, supra n. 22. \u00a7 2414; see also John Paul II, Veritatius Splendor no. 100."},{"key":"bibr43-20508549.2004.11877727","first-page":"517","volume":"64","author":"Noble-Allgire Alice N.","year":"1999","journal-title":"Mo. L Rev."},{"key":"bibr44-20508549.2004.11877727","unstructured":"See Johnson supra n. 24, at 137."},{"key":"bibr45-20508549.2004.11877727","unstructured":"Id. at 135"},{"key":"bibr46-20508549.2004.11877727","unstructured":"Id. at 156."},{"key":"bibr47-20508549.2004.11877727","unstructured":"812 F.2d 1239 (9th Cir. 1987); See also\n                      U.S. v. Boos\n                      , 127 F.3d 1207 (9th Cir. 1997);\n                      U.S. v. Sherman\n                      , 268 F.3d 539 (7th Cir. 2001)."},{"key":"bibr48-20508549.2004.11877727","unstructured":"Id. at 1245."},{"key":"bibr49-20508549.2004.11877727","unstructured":"Matter of Baby M., 547 A.2d 1227, 462-63 (1983)."},{"key":"bibr50-20508549.2004.11877727","unstructured":"Supra n.7."},{"key":"bibr51-20508549.2004.11877727","unstructured":"Id. As Belisto v. Clark pointed out, however, \u201cthe framers of those laws did not intend for the law to result in two mothers.\u201d\n                      Belisto\n                      , infra n.63, at 60."},{"key":"bibr52-20508549.2004.11877727","unstructured":"Id. at 782."},{"key":"bibr53-20508549.2004.11877727","first-page":"389","volume":"353","author":"Hill John Lawrence","year":"1991","journal-title":"N.Y.U.L. Rev."},{"key":"bibr54-20508549.2004.11877727","doi-asserted-by":"crossref","unstructured":"See generally ShultzMarjorie Maguire Article, \u201cReproductive Technology and Intent-Based Parenthood: An Opportunity for Gender Neutrality,\u201d (1990)\n                      Wis. L. Rev. 297\n                      : and Marjorie Maguire Shultz, Note,\n                      Redefining Mother: A Legal Matrix for New Reproductive Technologies\n                      , 396 Yale L.J. 187 (1986).","DOI":"10.2307\/796440"},{"key":"bibr55-20508549.2004.11877727","unstructured":"Johnson\n                      , supra n.6, at 782, quoting Hill, supra n.62, at 415."},{"key":"bibr56-20508549.2004.11877727","unstructured":"Id. at 783, quoting Shultz, supra n.54, 96\n                      Yale L.J.\n                      at 196."},{"key":"bibr57-20508549.2004.11877727","unstructured":"Id. at 782-83, quoting Shultz supra n.54, (1990) Wis. L. Rev. at 323."},{"key":"bibr58-20508549.2004.11877727","unstructured":"Hill supra n54, at 415-16."},{"key":"bibr59-20508549.2004.11877727","first-page":"496","volume":"17","author":"Coleman Malina","year":"1996","journal-title":"Cardozo L. Rev."},{"key":"bibr60-20508549.2004.11877727","unstructured":"Johnson\n                      , supra n.6, at 783, quoting Shultz, supra n.63, 96 Yale L.J. at 397."},{"key":"bibr61-20508549.2004.11877727","first-page":"265","volume":"80","author":"Schiff Anne Reichman","year":"1995","journal-title":"Iowa L. Rev."},{"key":"bibr62-20508549.2004.11877727","unstructured":"Johnson\n                      , supra n.6, at 783."},{"key":"bibr63-20508549.2004.11877727","unstructured":"Kennard ultimately advocated a \u201cbest interests of the child standard to determine natural paternity in ART cases. Id. at 799-800."},{"key":"bibr64-20508549.2004.11877727","unstructured":"Id."},{"key":"bibr65-20508549.2004.11877727","first-page":"287","volume":"77","year":"1988","journal-title":"Geo. L.J."},{"key":"bibr66-20508549.2004.11877727","unstructured":"Id. at 796-97."},{"key":"bibr67-20508549.2004.11877727","unstructured":"Noble-Allgire supra n.44, at 562."},{"key":"bibr68-20508549.2004.11877727","doi-asserted-by":"publisher","DOI":"10.2307\/1342435"},{"key":"bibr69-20508549.2004.11877727","doi-asserted-by":"publisher","DOI":"10.2307\/1322028"},{"key":"bibr70-20508549.2004.11877727","unstructured":"A potential risk involved in allowing a damage suit is that, if the damages were large enough, the contracting couple might offer to drop the suit in exchange for delivery of the child. In such instances, courts should he wary of allowing\n                      either type\n                      of suit, since the \u201csettlement offer\u201d might amount to blackmail."},{"key":"bibr71-20508549.2004.11877727","unstructured":"Garrison supra n. 69, at 861-63."},{"key":"bibr72-20508549.2004.11877727","unstructured":"Johnson\n                      , supra n.7, at 798."},{"key":"bibr73-20508549.2004.11877727","first-page":"872","volume":"2","author":"Mitchell Waldman J.D.","journal-title":"Am Jur"},{"key":"bibr74-20508549.2004.11877727","unstructured":"O'Hara & Vorzimer, supra n.4, at 35-36."},{"key":"bibr75-20508549.2004.11877727","unstructured":"Hurwitz supra n.5, at 143."},{"key":"bibr76-20508549.2004.11877727","unstructured":"Sec generally\n                      Huddleston v. Infertility Ctr. of America, Inc.\n                      , 700 A.2d 453 (Pa. Super. 1997)."},{"key":"bibr77-20508549.2004.11877727","unstructured":"Johnson\n                      , supra n.24, at 146-47: \u201cIt is the right and duty of parents under the law of nature as well as the common law and the statutes of many slates to protect their children, to care for them in sickness and in health, and to do whatever may be necessary for their care, maintenance, and preservation\u2026 An omission to discharge this duty is a public wrong which the state, under its police powers, may prevent.\u201d"},{"key":"bibr78-20508549.2004.11877727","unstructured":"See also\n                      People v. Sorenson\n                      , 68 Cal. 2d 280 (holding a father criminally liable for failing to pay child support to a child born to his wife from an anonymous sperm donation)."},{"key":"bibr79-20508549.2004.11877727","unstructured":"See Karin T. v. Michael T., 484 N.Y.S. 2d 780 (N.Y. Fam. Ct. 1995) (holding that a lesbian who changed her identity to male was the marital father of a partner's children born through artificial insemination)."},{"key":"bibr80-20508549.2004.11877727","unstructured":"Buzzanca\n                      , supra n.2, at 285-86."},{"key":"bibr81-20508549.2004.11877727","unstructured":"Id. at 288."},{"key":"bibr82-20508549.2004.11877727","unstructured":"Id. at 291."},{"key":"bibr83-20508549.2004.11877727","first-page":"241","volume":"39","author":"Brill Lara A.","year":"1999","journal-title":"Catholic Law."},{"key":"bibr84-20508549.2004.11877727","unstructured":"Waldman supra n. 85, at 929-932."},{"key":"bibr85-20508549.2004.11877727","unstructured":"Johnson\n                      , supra n.6, at 783, quoting Shultz, supra n.63, 96\n                      Yale L.J.\n                      at 397."},{"key":"bibr86-20508549.2004.11877727","unstructured":"48 Hours. \u201cWho's My Mommy?\u201d (CBS television broadcast. Aug. 17, 2001)."},{"key":"bibr87-20508549.2004.11877727","unstructured":"Modjtahedi supra n.84, at 269."},{"key":"bibr88-20508549.2004.11877727","unstructured":"Jaycee was born April 26, 1995;\n                      see Jaycee 8. v. Superior Ct.\n                      , Cal. App. 4th 718, 723: the appeal, in\n                      In re Buzzanca\n                      , was decided almost three years later."},{"key":"bibr89-20508549.2004.11877727","first-page":"523","volume":"32","author":"Dolgin Janet L.","year":"2000","journal-title":"Conn L. Rev."},{"key":"bibr90-20508549.2004.11877727","first-page":"951","volume":"47","author":"Rao Radhika","journal-title":"Hastings L.J"},{"key":"bibr91-20508549.2004.11877727","unstructured":"Id. at 962-63."},{"key":"bibr92-20508549.2004.11877727","unstructured":"Id. at 963-64."},{"key":"bibr93-20508549.2004.11877727","unstructured":"Id. at 964."},{"key":"bibr94-20508549.2004.11877727","unstructured":"Id. at 965-66."},{"key":"bibr95-20508549.2004.11877727","unstructured":"Id. at 961-62."},{"key":"bibr96-20508549.2004.11877727","unstructured":"Hurwitz supra n.6, at 142-43."},{"key":"bibr97-20508549.2004.11877727","first-page":"1","volume":"7","author":"McCully Melanie G.","year":"1998","journal-title":"J.L. & Po'y"},{"key":"bibr98-20508549.2004.11877727","unstructured":"164 Cal. Rptr.618 (Cal. Ct. App. 1980)."},{"key":"bibr99-20508549.2004.11877727","unstructured":"Brill supra n. 108, at 264-65; see also Hill, supra n.62, at 417."},{"key":"bibr100-20508549.2004.11877727","unstructured":"Id. at 263-64."},{"key":"bibr101-20508549.2004.11877727","unstructured":"Hurwitz supra n.6, at 143."},{"key":"bibr102-20508549.2004.11877727","unstructured":"Modjtahedi supra n.84, at 257."},{"key":"bibr103-20508549.2004.11877727","unstructured":"Hurwitz supra n.5, at 148."},{"key":"bibr104-20508549.2004.11877727","unstructured":"Modjtahedi supra n.84, at 259."},{"key":"bibr105-20508549.2004.11877727","unstructured":"Id. at 279."},{"key":"bibr106-20508549.2004.11877727","unstructured":"Id. at 274; see also Dolgin supra n. 10, at 1273."},{"key":"bibr107-20508549.2004.11877727","unstructured":"Supra n. 15, at 62."},{"key":"bibr108-20508549.2004.11877727","first-page":"1811","volume":"76","author":"Jackson Vicki C.","year":"1988","journal-title":"Geo L.J."},{"key":"bibr109-20508549.2004.11877727","unstructured":"Id."},{"key":"bibr110-20508549.2004.11877727","unstructured":"Dolgin supra n. 10, at 1294."},{"key":"bibr111-20508549.2004.11877727","unstructured":"Jackson supra n. 134, at 1818-19."},{"key":"bibr112-20508549.2004.11877727","unstructured":"Setoff supra n.62, at 278."},{"key":"bibr113-20508549.2004.11877727","first-page":"79","volume":"39","author":"Roosevelt Kermit","year":"1998","journal-title":"Santo Clara L. Rev."},{"key":"bibr114-20508549.2004.11877727","unstructured":"Id. at 88."},{"key":"bibr115-20508549.2004.11877727","unstructured":"Id. at 81."},{"key":"bibr116-20508549.2004.11877727","unstructured":"Id. at 81."},{"key":"bibr117-20508549.2004.11877727","unstructured":"Id. at 80-81."},{"key":"bibr118-20508549.2004.11877727","unstructured":"See, e.g. Schiff supra n.62, at 267."},{"key":"bibr119-20508549.2004.11877727","unstructured":"Cf.\n                      In re Estate of Gardinier\n                      , 42 P.3d 120 (Kan. 2002) (holding that a male-to-female transsexual was not a female within the meaning of a Kansas marriage statute); William Saletan, in\n                      Of Marriage and Mutable Gender\n                      (March 21, 2002), available at http:\/\/www.msnbc.com\/news\/727503asp. remarks that \u201c[t]he court\u2026 refused to give up the crazy notion that a birth certificate is supposed to certify what actually happened.\u201d"},{"key":"bibr120-20508549.2004.11877727","unstructured":"George Orwell, 1984, 205 (Penguin Books 1981) (1950)."},{"key":"bibr121-20508549.2004.11877727","unstructured":"Dolgin supra n. 226, at 1295."},{"key":"bibr122-20508549.2004.11877727","first-page":"538","volume":"28","author":"Dolgin Janet L.","year":"1996","journal-title":"Ariz. St. L.J."},{"key":"bibr123-20508549.2004.11877727","unstructured":"Garrison supra n. 69, at 865."}],"container-title":["The Linacre Quarterly"],"original-title":[],"language":"en","link":[{"URL":"https:\/\/journals.sagepub.com\/doi\/pdf\/10.1080\/20508549.2004.11877727","content-type":"application\/pdf","content-version":"vor","intended-application":"text-mining"},{"URL":"https:\/\/journals.sagepub.com\/doi\/full-xml\/10.1080\/20508549.2004.11877727","content-type":"application\/xml","content-version":"vor","intended-application":"text-mining"},{"URL":"https:\/\/journals.sagepub.com\/doi\/pdf\/10.1080\/20508549.2004.11877727","content-type":"unspecified","content-version":"vor","intended-application":"similarity-checking"}],"deposited":{"date-parts":[[2026,5,1]],"date-time":"2026-05-01T12:13:51Z","timestamp":1777637631000},"score":1,"resource":{"primary":{"URL":"https:\/\/journals.sagepub.com\/doi\/10.1080\/20508549.2004.11877727"}},"subtitle":[],"short-title":[],"issued":{"date-parts":[[2004,11]]},"references-count":124,"journal-issue":{"issue":"4","published-print":{"date-parts":[[2004,11]]}},"alternative-id":["10.1080\/20508549.2004.11877727"],"URL":"https:\/\/doi.org\/10.1080\/20508549.2004.11877727","relation":{},"ISSN":["0024-3639","2050-8549"],"issn-type":[{"value":"0024-3639","type":"print"},{"value":"2050-8549","type":"electronic"}],"subject":[],"published":{"date-parts":[[2004,11]]}}}