{"status":"ok","message-type":"work","message-version":"1.0.0","message":{"indexed":{"date-parts":[[2026,5,5]],"date-time":"2026-05-05T06:51:54Z","timestamp":1777963914755,"version":"3.51.4"},"reference-count":70,"publisher":"Oxford University Press (OUP)","issue":"1","license":[{"start":{"date-parts":[[2023,8,24]],"date-time":"2023-08-24T00:00:00Z","timestamp":1692835200000},"content-version":"vor","delay-in-days":235,"URL":"https:\/\/creativecommons.org\/licenses\/by\/4.0\/"}],"content-domain":{"domain":[],"crossmark-restriction":false},"short-container-title":[],"published-print":{"date-parts":[[2023,1,5]]},"abstract":"<jats:title>Abstract<\/jats:title>\n               <jats:p>Much research on influence operations (IO) and cyber-enabled influence operations (CEIO) rests on the assumption that state-backed digital interference attempts to generically produce sociopolitical division favorable to the perpetrator\u2019s own interests. And yet, the empirical record of malicious IO during the 2010s show that social media manipulation and messaging takes a number of forms. In this article, we survey arguments regarding the targeting tactics and techniques associated with digital age IO and suggest that existing accounts tend to ignore the strategic context of foreign interference. We propose that state-sponsored IO are not unlike conventional political messaging campaigns in that they are an evolving flow of information rooted in several key objectives and assumptions. However, the strategic position of foreign actors as an outside force constrains opportunities for effective manipulation and forces certain operational constraints that shape practice. These outside actors, generally unable to create sensation from nothing without being unveiled, rely on domestic events tied to a broad macrosocial division (e.g. an act of race violence or protest activity) to create the conditions wherein social media manipulation can be leveraged to strategic gain. Once an event occurs, belligerents tailor steps being taken to embed themselves in relevant social networks with the goal of turning that influence toward some action. We illustrate and validate this framework using the content of the Russian Federation\u2019s coordinated trolling campaign against the USA between 2015 and 2016. We deploy an empirical testing approach centered on fear appeals as a likely method for engaging foreign populations relative to some domestic triggering event and find support of our framework. Specifically, we show that while strong associations exist between Russian ad emissions on Facebook and societal unrest in the period, those relationships are not statistically causal. We find a temporal ordering of social media content that is highly suggestive of a fear appeals strategy responsive to macrosocial dividing events. Of unique interest, we also see that malware is targeted to social media populations at later stages of the fear appeal threat lifecycle, implying lessons for those specifically interested in the relationship between CEIO and disinformation tactics.<\/jats:p>","DOI":"10.1093\/cybsec\/tyad016","type":"journal-article","created":{"date-parts":[[2023,8,24]],"date-time":"2023-08-24T15:16:54Z","timestamp":1692890214000},"source":"Crossref","is-referenced-by-count":7,"title":["From Russia with fear: fear appeals and the patterns of cyber-enabled influence operations"],"prefix":"10.1093","volume":"9","author":[{"given":"Ugochukwu","family":"Etudo","sequence":"first","affiliation":[{"name":"School of Business, Virginia Commonwealth University , 301 W Main St, Richmond, VA 23284 , USA"}],"role":[{"role":"author","vocabulary":"crossref"}]},{"ORCID":"https:\/\/orcid.org\/0000-0003-4522-465X","authenticated-orcid":false,"given":"Christopher","family":"Whyte","sequence":"additional","affiliation":[{"name":"L. Douglas Wilder School of Government and Public Affairs, Virginia Commonwealth University , 923 W Franklin St, Richmond, VA 23284 , USA"}],"role":[{"role":"author","vocabulary":"crossref"}]},{"given":"Victoria","family":"Yoon","sequence":"additional","affiliation":[{"name":"School of Business, Virginia Commonwealth University , 301 W Main St, Richmond, VA 23284 , USA"}],"role":[{"role":"author","vocabulary":"crossref"}]},{"given":"Niam","family":"Yaraghi","sequence":"additional","affiliation":[{"name":"Miami Herbert Business School, University of Miami , 5250 University Dr, Coral Gables, FL 33146 , USA"}],"role":[{"role":"author","vocabulary":"crossref"}]}],"member":"286","published-online":{"date-parts":[[2023,8,24]]},"reference":[{"key":"2023082415395407300_bib1","doi-asserted-by":"crossref","first-page":"122","DOI":"10.1177\/0267323118760317","article-title":"The disinformation order: disruptive communication and the decline of democratic institutions","volume":"33","author":"Bennett","year":"2018","journal-title":"Eur J Commun"},{"key":"2023082415395407300_bib2","volume-title":"TheIRA, Social Media and Political Polarization in the United States, 2012\u20132018","author":"Howard","year":"2018"},{"issue":"3","key":"2023082415395407300_bib70_1691574589001","doi-asserted-by":"crossref","first-page":"357","DOI":"10.1177\/1940161220912682","article-title":"Cross-platform state propaganda: Russian trolls on twitter and YouTube during the 2016 US Presidential Election","volume":"25","author":"Golovchenko","year":"2020","journal-title":"Int J Press\/Politics"},{"key":"2023082415395407300_bib4","doi-asserted-by":"crossref","first-page":"1","DOI":"10.1371\/journal.pone.0222713","article-title":"Self multi-head attention-based convolutional neural networks for fake news detection","volume":"14","author":"Fang","year":"2019","journal-title":"PLoS One"},{"key":"2023082415395407300_bib33","volume-title":"Active Measures: The Secret History of Disinformation and Political Warfare","author":"Rid","year":"2020"},{"key":"2023082415395407300_bib36","article-title":"Cyber-enabled influence operations as a \u2018center of gravity\u2019 in cyber conflict: the example of Russian foreign interference in the 2016 U.S. Federal election","author":"Vicic","year":"2022"},{"issue":"5","key":"2023082415395407300_bib3","doi-asserted-by":"crossref","first-page":"1826","DOI":"10.1287\/mnsc.2019.3295","article-title":"Fake news propagation and detection: A sequential model","volume":"66","author":"Papanastasiou","year":"2020","journal-title":"Manage Sci"},{"key":"2023082415395407300_bib5","doi-asserted-by":"crossref","first-page":"1025","DOI":"10.25300\/MISQ\/2019\/15188","article-title":"Says who? The effects of presentation format and source rating on fake news in social media","volume":"43","author":"Kim","year":"2019","journal-title":"MIS Q Manag Inf Syst"},{"key":"2023082415395407300_bib6","doi-asserted-by":"crossref","first-page":"388","DOI":"10.1016\/j.tics.2021.02.007","article-title":"The psychology of fake news","volume":"25","author":"Pennycook","year":"2021","journal-title":"Trends Cogn Sci"},{"key":"2023082415395407300_bib7","doi-asserted-by":"crossref","first-page":"329","DOI":"10.1016\/j.jbusres.2020.11.037","article-title":"Fake news, social media and marketing: a systematic review","volume":"124","author":"Di\u00a0Domenico","year":"2021","journal-title":"J Bus Res"},{"key":"2023082415395407300_bib8","doi-asserted-by":"crossref","first-page":"931","DOI":"10.1080\/07421222.2019.1628921","article-title":"Combating fake news on social media with source ratings: the effects of user and expert reputation ratings","volume":"36","author":"Kim","year":"2019","journal-title":"J Manag Inf Syst"},{"key":"2023082415395407300_bib9","doi-asserted-by":"crossref","first-page":"919","DOI":"10.1287\/mnsc.2015.2378","article-title":"Dynamic pricing in the presence of social learning and strategic consumers","volume":"63","author":"Papanastasiou","year":"2017","journal-title":"Manage Sci"},{"key":"2023082415395407300_bib10","doi-asserted-by":"crossref","first-page":"329","DOI":"10.1080\/03637759209376276","article-title":"Putting the fear back into fear appeals: the extended parallel process model","volume":"59","author":"Witte","year":"1992","journal-title":"Commun Monogr"},{"key":"2023082415395407300_bib11","first-page":"10","article-title":"The web of false information: rumors, fake news, hoaxes, clickbait, and various other shenanigans","volume":"11","author":"Zannettou","year":"2019","journal-title":"J Data Inf Qual"},{"key":"2023082415395407300_bib12","article-title":"Disinformation warfare: understanding state-sponsored trolls on Twitter and their influence on the web","volume-title":"WWW '19: Companion Proceedings of The 2019 World Wide Web Conference","author":"Zannettou","year":"2018"},{"key":"2023082415395407300_bib13","first-page":"308","article-title":"Information warfare as the hobbesian concept of modern times\u2014the principles, techniques, and tools of Russian information operations in the donbass","volume":"31","author":"M\u00f6ldera","year":"2018","journal-title":"J Slav Mil Stud"},{"key":"2023082415395407300_bib14","doi-asserted-by":"crossref","first-page":"729","DOI":"10.1287\/orsc.1070.0340","article-title":"Framing contests: strategy making under uncertainty","volume":"19","author":"Kaplan","year":"2008","journal-title":"Organ Sci"},{"key":"2023082415395407300_bib15","article-title":"Examining trolls and polarization with a retweet network","volume":"6","author":"Stewart","year":"2018","journal-title":"Proc WSDM Work Misinformation Misbehavior Min Web (MIS2)"},{"key":"2023082415395407300_bib16","doi-asserted-by":"crossref","first-page":"203","DOI":"10.1007\/s11109-015-9316-6","article-title":"Participation in the wake of adversity: blame attribution and policy-oriented evaluations","volume":"38","author":"Levin","year":"2016","journal-title":"Polit Behav"},{"key":"2023082415395407300_bib17","doi-asserted-by":"crossref","DOI":"10.1093\/oso\/9780197519882.001.0001","volume-title":"Meddling in the Ballot Box: the Causes and Effects of Partisan Electoral Interventions","author":"Levin","year":"2020"},{"key":"2023082415395407300_bib18","doi-asserted-by":"crossref","first-page":"tyaa013","DOI":"10.1093\/cybsec\/tyaa013","article-title":"Cyber conflict or democracy \u201chacked\u201d? How cyber operations enhance information warfare","volume":"6","author":"Whyte","year":"2020","journal-title":"J Cybersecurity"},{"key":"2023082415395407300_bib19","article-title":"Understanding Russian \u201cHybrid Warfare\u201d","volume":"17","author":"Chivvis","year":"2017","journal-title":"Rand Corp"},{"key":"2023082415395407300_bib20","doi-asserted-by":"crossref","DOI":"10.4324\/9780429470509","volume-title":"Information Warfare in the Age of Cyber Conflict","author":"Whyte","year":"2020"},{"key":"2023082415395407300_bib21","doi-asserted-by":"crossref","first-page":"54","DOI":"10.4324\/9780429470509-5","article-title":"Cyber conflict AT the intersection of information operations","volume-title":"Information Warfare in the Age of Cyber Conflict","author":"Foote","year":"2020"},{"key":"2023082415395407300_bib22","doi-asserted-by":"crossref","first-page":"15","DOI":"10.4324\/9780429470509-2","article-title":"The convergence of information warfare","volume-title":"Information Warfare in the Age of Cyber Conflict","author":"Libicki","year":"2020"},{"key":"2023082415395407300_bib23","doi-asserted-by":"crossref","first-page":"195","DOI":"10.1017\/eis.2020.2","article-title":"Beyond tit-for-tat in cyberspace: political warfare and lateral sources of escalation online","volume":"5","author":"Whyte","year":"2020","journal-title":"Eur J Int Secur"},{"key":"2023082415395407300_bib24","article-title":"Russia has been meddling in foreign elections for decades. Has it made a difference?","volume-title":"The Washington Post","author":"Way","year":"2018"},{"key":"2023082415395407300_bib25","doi-asserted-by":"crossref","first-page":"234","DOI":"10.1080\/14781158.2020.1692334","article-title":"New technologies and the law in war and peace","volume":"32","author":"O'Connor","year":"2020","journal-title":"Glob Change Peace Secur"},{"key":"2023082415395407300_bib26","doi-asserted-by":"crossref","DOI":"10.5210\/spir.v2020i0.11132","article-title":"\u2018Coordinated inauthentic behaviour\u2019 and other online influence operations in social media spaces","author":"Keller","year":"2020","journal-title":"AoIR Selected Papers of Internet Research"},{"key":"2023082415395407300_bib27","article-title":"Disinformation warfare\u202f: understanding state-sponsored trolls on Twitter and their influence on the web","volume-title":"WWW '19: Companion Proceedings of The 2019 World Wide Web Conference","author":"Zannettou","year":"2017"},{"key":"2023082415395407300_bib28","doi-asserted-by":"crossref","first-page":"1505","DOI":"10.1177\/1071181320641360","article-title":"For whom the tale's told: towards a multidimensional model of targeted narrative persuasion in information operations","volume":"64","author":"Song","year":"2020","journal-title":"Proc Hum Factors Ergon Soc Annu Meet"},{"key":"2023082415395407300_bib29","doi-asserted-by":"crossref","first-page":"292","DOI":"10.1016\/j.chb.2019.05.027","article-title":"THE RUSSIANS ARE HACKING MY BRAIN!\u201d investigating Russia\u2019s internet research agency twitter tactics during the 2016 United States presidential campaign","volume":"99","author":"Linvill","year":"2019","journal-title":"Comput Human Behav"},{"key":"2023082415395407300_bib30","doi-asserted-by":"crossref","first-page":"245","DOI":"10.1111\/1467-923X.12690","article-title":"How Russia\u2019s internet research agency built its disinformation campaign","volume":"90","author":"Dawson","year":"2019","journal-title":"Polit Q"},{"key":"2023082415395407300_bib31","doi-asserted-by":"crossref","first-page":"196","DOI":"10.1177\/1940161219895215","article-title":"The wolves in sheep\u2019s clothing: how Russia\u2019s Internet Research Agency tweets appeared in US news as vox populi","volume":"25","author":"Lukito","year":"2020","journal-title":"Int J Press"},{"key":"2023082415395407300_bib32","doi-asserted-by":"crossref","first-page":"143","DOI":"10.1093\/ijpor\/edz003","article-title":"A new Cold War? International public opinion of Russia and the United States","volume":"32","author":"Fisher","year":"2020","journal-title":"Int J Public Opin Res"},{"key":"2023082415395407300_bib34","doi-asserted-by":"crossref","first-page":"27","DOI":"10.4324\/9780429470509-3","article-title":"A brief history of fake: surveying Russian disinformation from the Russian Empire through the Cold War and to the present","volume-title":"Information Warfare in the Age of Cyber Conflict","author":"Brantly","year":"2020"},{"key":"2023082415395407300_bib35","doi-asserted-by":"crossref","DOI":"10.4324\/9781003110224-13","article-title":"Battling the bear","volume-title":"Cyber Security Politics","author":"Brantly","year":"2022"},{"key":"2023082415395407300_bib37","first-page":"55","article-title":"The Russian model of digital control and its significance","author":"Kerr","year":"2018","journal-title":"Artificial Intelligence, China, Russia, and the Global Order Air University Press"},{"key":"2023082415395407300_bib38","article-title":"On cyber-enabled information\/influence warfare and manipulation","author":"Lin","year":"2017","journal-title":"Center for International Security and Cooperation (CISAC)"},{"key":"2023082415395407300_bib39","first-page":"743","article-title":"Fear, anger, and political advertisement engagement: a computational case study of Russian-linked Facebook and Instagram content","volume-title":"Journal Mass Commun Q","author":"Vargo","year":"2020"},{"key":"2023082415395407300_bib40","article-title":"Analysis of strategy and spread of Russia-sponsored content in the US in 2017","volume-title":"arXiv:1810.10033","author":"Spangher","year":"2018"},{"key":"2023082415395407300_bib41","article-title":"Facebook ad engagement in the russian active measures campaign of 2016","volume-title":"arXiv:2012.11690","author":"Silva","year":"2020"},{"key":"2023082415395407300_bib42","doi-asserted-by":"crossref","first-page":"1178","DOI":"10.1037\/a0039729","article-title":"Appealing to fear: a meta-analysis of fear appeal effectiveness and theories","volume":"141","author":"Tannenbaum","year":"2015","journal-title":"Psychol Bull"},{"key":"2023082415395407300_bib43","volume-title":"Cyberwar: How Russian Hackers and Trolls Helped Elect a President What We Don't, Can't, and Do Know","author":"Jamieson","year":"2018"},{"key":"2023082415395407300_bib44","doi-asserted-by":"crossref","first-page":"1","DOI":"10.1080\/1057610X.2014.974948","article-title":"Tweeting the Jihad: social media networks of western foreign fighters in Syria and Iraq","volume":"38","author":"Klausen","year":"2015","journal-title":"Stud Confl Terror"},{"key":"2023082415395407300_bib45","doi-asserted-by":"crossref","first-page":"166","DOI":"10.1016\/S0065-2601(08)60344-5","article-title":"Effects of fear arousal on attitude change: recent developments in theory and experimental research","volume":"3","author":"Janis","year":"1967","journal-title":"Adv Exp Soc Psychol"},{"key":"2023082415395407300_bib46","doi-asserted-by":"crossref","first-page":"119","DOI":"10.1016\/S0065-2601(08)60091-X","article-title":"Findings and theory in the study of fear communications","volume":"5","author":"Leventhal","year":"1970","journal-title":"Adv Exp Soc Psychol"},{"key":"2023082415395407300_bib47","doi-asserted-by":"crossref","first-page":"93","DOI":"10.1080\/00223980.1975.9915803","article-title":"A protection motivation theory of fear appeals and attitude change1","volume":"91","author":"Rogers","year":"1975","journal-title":"J Psychol"},{"key":"2023082415395407300_bib48","doi-asserted-by":"crossref","first-page":"222","DOI":"10.1037\/0022-3514.32.2.222","article-title":"Effects of fear appeals and physiological arousal upon emotion, attitudes, and cigarette smoking","volume":"32","author":"Rogers","year":"1975","journal-title":"J Pers Soc Psychol"},{"key":"2023082415395407300_bib49","article-title":"The people's choice: how the voter makes up his mind in a presidential campaign","author":"Lazarsfeld","year":"1944"},{"key":"2023082415395407300_bib50","doi-asserted-by":"crossref","DOI":"10.4324\/9781315126234","volume-title":"Personal influence: The part played by people in the flow of mass communications","author":"Katz","year":"2017"},{"key":"2023082415395407300_bib51","doi-asserted-by":"crossref","first-page":"206","DOI":"10.1111\/j.1751-9004.2011.00341.x","article-title":"Fear appeals and persuasion: a review and update of the extended parallel process model","volume":"5","author":"Maloney","year":"2011","journal-title":"Soc Personal Psychol Compass"},{"key":"2023082415395407300_bib52","first-page":"197","article-title":"Ideology, frame resonance, and participant mobilization","volume":"1","author":"Snow","year":"1988","journal-title":"Int Soc Mov Res"},{"key":"2023082415395407300_bib53","doi-asserted-by":"crossref","first-page":"559","DOI":"10.1086\/230316","article-title":"The mangle of practice\u202f: agency and emergence in the sociology of Science1","volume":"99","author":"Pickering","year":"1993","journal-title":"Am J Sociol"},{"key":"2023082415395407300_bib54","doi-asserted-by":"crossref","first-page":"258","DOI":"10.1037\/1089-2680.11.3.258","article-title":"The impact of vulnerability to and severity of a health risk on processing and acceptance of fear-arousing communications: a meta-analysis","volume":"11","author":"de\u00a0Hoog","year":"2007","journal-title":"Rev Gen Psychol"},{"key":"2023082415395407300_bib55","doi-asserted-by":"crossref","DOI":"10.4324\/9781315575827","volume-title":"Dangerous Others, Insecure Societies: Fear and Social Division","author":"Lianos","year":"2016"},{"key":"2023082415395407300_bib56","doi-asserted-by":"crossref","first-page":"419","DOI":"10.2307\/3791357","article-title":"How West German adolescents experience the nuclear threat","volume":"10","author":"Boehnke","year":"1989","journal-title":"Polit Psychol"},{"key":"2023082415395407300_bib57","doi-asserted-by":"crossref","first-page":"65","DOI":"10.1080\/14616690601079440","article-title":"Social change as a source of macrosocial stress: does it enhance nationalistic attitudes? A cross-cultural study of effects of the EU eastern enlargement","volume":"9","author":"Boehnke","year":"2007","journal-title":"Eur Soc"},{"key":"2023082415395407300_bib58","article-title":"State propaganda in the age of social media: examining strategies of the Internet Research Agency","volume-title":"7th European Communication Conference (ECC), Lugano, Switzerland (31 October\u20133 November)","author":"Farkas","year":"2018"},{"key":"2023082415395407300_bib59","first-page":"556","article-title":"Algorithms for non-negative matrix factorization","author":"Lee","year":"2001","journal-title":"Adv Neural Inf Process Syst"},{"key":"2023082415395407300_bib60","first-page":"389","article-title":"Jack of all, master of some: information network and Innovation in crowdsourcing communities","volume-title":"Inf Syst Res","author":"Hwang","year":"2019"},{"key":"2023082415395407300_bib61","first-page":"1","article-title":"Reading tea leaves: how humans interpret topic models","author":"Chang","year":"2009","journal-title":"NIPS'09: Proceedings of the 22nd International Conference on Neural Information Processing Systems"},{"key":"2023082415395407300_bib62","doi-asserted-by":"crossref","first-page":"552","DOI":"10.1057\/s41309-020-00105-w","article-title":"Review essay: connecting elections and protests","volume":"9","author":"Heaney","year":"2020","journal-title":"Interest Groups Advocacy"},{"key":"2023082415395407300_bib63","volume-title":"The Loud Minority: Why Protests Matter in American Democracy","author":"Gillion","year":"2020"},{"key":"2023082415395407300_bib64","first-page":"343","article-title":"Segmented: an R package to fit regression models with broken-line relationships","volume":"3","author":"Muggeo","year":"2008","journal-title":"R News"},{"key":"2023082415395407300_bib65","doi-asserted-by":"crossref","first-page":"146","DOI":"10.1287\/isre.1120.0462","article-title":"Social media and firm equity value","volume":"24","author":"Luo","year":"2013","journal-title":"Inf Syst Res"},{"key":"2023082415395407300_bib66","volume-title":"Multivariate Time Series Analysis: With R and Financial Applications","author":"Tsay","year":"2013"},{"key":"2023082415395407300_bib67","first-page":"4267","article-title":"Neural granger causality for nonlinear time series","volume":"44","author":"Tank","year":"2018","journal-title":"IEEE Trans Pattern Anal Mach Intell"},{"key":"2023082415395407300_bib68","first-page":"14","volume-title":"Assessing Russian Activities and Intentions in Recent US Elections","author":"National Intelligence Council","year":"2017"},{"key":"2023082415395407300_bib69","doi-asserted-by":"crossref","first-page":"1","DOI":"10.1145\/1314389.1314391","article-title":"A framework for detection and measurement of phishing attacks","volume-title":"Proceedings of the 2007 ACM Workshop on Recurring Malcode","author":"Garera","year":"2007"}],"container-title":["Journal of Cybersecurity"],"original-title":[],"language":"en","link":[{"URL":"https:\/\/academic.oup.com\/cybersecurity\/article-pdf\/9\/1\/tyad016\/51246012\/tyad016.pdf","content-type":"application\/pdf","content-version":"vor","intended-application":"syndication"},{"URL":"https:\/\/academic.oup.com\/cybersecurity\/article-pdf\/9\/1\/tyad016\/51246012\/tyad016.pdf","content-type":"unspecified","content-version":"vor","intended-application":"similarity-checking"}],"deposited":{"date-parts":[[2023,8,24]],"date-time":"2023-08-24T15:42:44Z","timestamp":1692891764000},"score":1,"resource":{"primary":{"URL":"https:\/\/academic.oup.com\/cybersecurity\/article\/doi\/10.1093\/cybsec\/tyad016\/7250062"}},"subtitle":[],"short-title":[],"issued":{"date-parts":[[2023,1,1]]},"references-count":70,"journal-issue":{"issue":"1","published-print":{"date-parts":[[2023,1,5]]}},"URL":"https:\/\/doi.org\/10.1093\/cybsec\/tyad016","relation":{},"ISSN":["2057-2085","2057-2093"],"issn-type":[{"value":"2057-2085","type":"print"},{"value":"2057-2093","type":"electronic"}],"subject":[],"published-other":{"date-parts":[[2023,1,1]]},"published":{"date-parts":[[2023,1,1]]},"article-number":"tyad016"}}