{"status":"ok","message-type":"work","message-version":"1.0.0","message":{"indexed":{"date-parts":[[2026,11,11]],"date-time":"2026-11-11T20:22:30Z","timestamp":1794428550249,"version":"4.9.1"},"reference-count":155,"publisher":"IBFD","issue":"11","content-domain":{"domain":[],"crossmark-restriction":false},"short-container-title":["Intl. Tax Stud."],"published-print":{"date-parts":[[2026,11,4]]},"abstract":"<jats:p>This study examines the digital transformation of tax administration in Sweden and Ukraine through a dynamic approach to comparative jurisprudence. By analysing legal frameworks, institutional arrangements and emerging GovTech practices, it moves beyond conventional comparisons of tax systems to investigate how data-driven ecosystems reshape administrative processes. The research highlights how both countries \u2013 despite differing levels of economic development and digital maturity \u2013 integrate technological tools, platforms and AI into their tax administrations. In doing so, the study addresses a comparatively underexplored pairing in tax scholarship and offers new insights into the relationship between technological innovation, regulatory design and administrative capacity. The findings contribute to broader discussions on digital taxation, administrative modernization and the evolving role of law in governing data-intensive public institutions.<\/jats:p>","DOI":"10.59403\/302fw4w","type":"journal-article","created":{"date-parts":[[2026,11,4]],"date-time":"2026-11-04T19:45:09Z","timestamp":1793821509000},"source":"Crossref","is-referenced-by-count":0,"title":["At the Edge of the State: Tax Law, AI and the Rise of Embedded Governance"],"prefix":"10.59403","volume":"9","author":[{"given":"Vadym","family":"Tsymbal","sequence":"first","affiliation":[],"role":[{"vocabulary":"crossref","role":"author"}]}],"member":"38363","reference":[{"key":"10","unstructured":"Dr Vadym Tsymbal is an independent researcher located in \u00d6rebro, Sweden, specializing in public sector transformation, with a particular focus on the OECD Tax Administration 3.0 framework and comparative tax administration. The author can be contacted at vadym.tsymbal.ua@gmail.com."},{"key":"13","unstructured":"This research was conducted independently by the author, without external funding or institutional financial support, and was undertaken in the author's personal time."},{"key":"47","doi-asserted-by":"publisher","DOI":"10.1111\/0033-3352.00168"},{"key":"50","unstructured":"Henry Mintzberg, Structure in Fives: Designing Effective Organizations (Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice-Hall, 1983)."},{"key":"56","unstructured":"Friedrich A. Hayek, The Road to Serfdom (London: Routledge, 1944), 45, and Friedrich A. Hayek, The Constitution of Liberty (Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1960), 262, cited in Bovens and Zouridis, \u201cStreet-Level to System-Level Bureaucracies\u201d, 174."},{"key":"61","unstructured":"Michael Lipsky, \u201cThe Critical Role of Street-Level Bureaucrats\", in Street-Level Bureaucracy: Dilemmas of the Individual in Public Services (New York: Russell Sage Foundation, 1980), 3-12, http:\/\/www.jstor.org\/stable\/10.7758\/9781610447713.5."},{"key":"66","unstructured":"Bovens and Zouridis, \u201cStreet-Level to System-Level Bureaucracies\", 174-184."},{"key":"69","unstructured":"Bovens and Zouridis, \u201cStreet-Level to System-Level Bureaucracies\", 175."},{"key":"71","unstructured":"Stavros Zouridis, Marlies van Eck and Mark Bovens, \u201cWP.2019.006: Zouridis\u2013Van Eck\u2013Bovens (eLaw Working Paper)\", eLaw Working Paper Series, Universiteit Leiden, 2019, 15, https:\/\/www.universiteitleiden.nl\/binaries\/content\/assets\/rechtsgeleerdheid\/instituut-voor-metajuridica\/elaw-working-paper-series\/wp.2019.006._zouridis-van-eck-and-bovens.pdf."},{"key":"74","unstructured":"Bovens and Zouridis, \u201cStreet-Level to System-Level Bureaucracies\", 174-184."},{"key":"77","unstructured":"Bovens and Zouridis, \u201cStreet-Level to System-Level Bureaucracies\", 174-184."},{"key":"80","unstructured":"M. J. van den Hooven, \u201cMoral Responsibility, Public Office and Information Technology\", in Public Administration in an Information Age: A Handbook, eds. I. Th. M. Snellen and W. B. H. J. van de Donk (Amsterdam: IOS Press, 1998), 105 (example page from original chapter), cited in Bovens and Zouridis, \u201cStreet-Level to System-Level Bureaucracies\", 179."},{"key":"84","doi-asserted-by":"crossref","unstructured":"Zouridis, Van Eck and Bovens, \u201cWP.2019.006\u201d.","DOI":"10.5465\/AMBPP.2019.17551abstract"},{"key":"88","unstructured":"Lipsky, Street-Level Bureaucracy, 159-179."},{"key":"93","unstructured":"IBM, \u201cWhat is Industry 4.0?\", https:\/\/www.ibm.com\/think\/topics\/industry-4-0 (accessed 2 Sept. 2025)."},{"key":"98","doi-asserted-by":"publisher","DOI":"10.1787\/9789264312012-en"},{"key":"102","unstructured":"Andres Raieste, P\u00e4rt Ojamaa and Mihkel Solvak, Personal Government\u2014A Vision for a Postdigital Era of Equitable and Sustainable Public Services (Tallinn, Estonia: Nortal and University of Tartu, 2023), 4."},{"key":"105","unstructured":"OECD, Going Digital, 31."},{"key":"110","doi-asserted-by":"publisher","DOI":"10.1787\/ca274cc5-en"},{"key":"115","doi-asserted-by":"publisher","DOI":"10.1787\/c076d776-en"},{"key":"119","unstructured":"Ibid."},{"key":"121","unstructured":"Ibid., 11."},{"key":"124","doi-asserted-by":"crossref","unstructured":"Zouridis, Van Eck and Bovens, \u201cWP.2019.006\u201d.","DOI":"10.5465\/AMBPP.2019.17551abstract"},{"key":"127","unstructured":"Ibid."},{"key":"131","unstructured":"Lipsky, Street-Level Bureaucracy, 192-212."},{"key":"135","unstructured":"OECD, Going Digital."},{"key":"139","doi-asserted-by":"crossref","unstructured":"Zouridis, Van Eck and Bovens, \u201cWP.2019.006\", 11-13.","DOI":"10.1080\/17476348.2019.1667234"},{"key":"143","unstructured":"OECD, Going Digital, 30."},{"key":"147","unstructured":"European Commission, Commission Staff Working Document: Executive Summary of the Impact Assessment Report Accompanying the document Proposal for a REGULATION OF THE EUROPEAN PARLIAMENT AND OF THE COUNCIL laying down measures for a high level of public sector interoperability across the Union (Interoperable Europe Act), SWD(2022) 722 final (Brussels, 2022), https:\/\/eur-lex.europa.eu\/legal-content\/EN\/TXT\/HTML\/?uri=CELEX:52022SC0722."},{"key":"152","unstructured":"Ibid."},{"key":"155","unstructured":"OECD, Tax Administration 3.0, 38."},{"key":"158","unstructured":"Ibid., 49."},{"key":"161","unstructured":"Ibid., 13."},{"key":"163","unstructured":"Ibid., 72."},{"key":"165","unstructured":"Ibid., 48."},{"key":"168","unstructured":"OECD, Going Digital, 31."},{"key":"174","unstructured":"OECD, Tax Administration Digitalisation, 12."},{"key":"178","unstructured":"Skatteverket, Ramverk f\u00f6r Skatteverkets digitala transformation 2024\u20132030 [Framework for the Swedish Tax Agency's digital transformation 2024\u20132030] (Stockholm: Skatteverket, 2024), https:\/\/www.skatteverket.se\/download\/18.25688d121956e35b0c22c35\/1745528396697\/ramverk-for-skatteverkets-digitala-transformation-2024-2030.pdf."},{"key":"183","unstructured":"Ibid., 16."},{"key":"186","unstructured":"Ibid., 5."},{"key":"189","doi-asserted-by":"crossref","unstructured":"Derzhavna Podatkova Sluzhba Ukrainy, Nakaz vid 21.02.2025 \u2116 150 \u201cPro zatverdzhennia misii ta Stratehichnoho planu Derzhavno\u00ef podatkovo\u00ef sluzhby Ukrainy na 2025\u20132030 roky\u201d [Order from 21.02.2025 No. 150 \u201cOn the Approval of the Mission and Strategic Plan of the State Tax Service of Ukraine for 2025\u20132030\u201d] (Kyiv, 2025), https:\/\/tax.gov.ua\/diyalnist-\/zakonodavstvo-pro-diyalnis\/nakazi-pro-diyalnist\/79393.html.","DOI":"10.1055\/a-2496-9730"},{"key":"193","unstructured":"Derzhavna Podatkova Sluzhba Ukrainy, \u201cM\u0456s\u0456ya ta strateg\u0456chn\u0456 ts\u0456l\u0456\u201d [Mission and strategic goals], 2025, https:\/\/tax.gov.ua\/pro-sts-ukraini\/misiya-ta-strategichni-tsili."},{"key":"197","unstructured":"Ibid."},{"key":"200","unstructured":"Ministerstvo Finansiv Ukrainy, National Revenue Strategy until 2030 [Natsional\u02b9na stratehiya dokhodiv do 2030 roku] (Kyiv, 2023), https:\/\/mof.gov.ua\/storage\/files\/National%20Revenue%20Strategy_2030_.pdf."},{"key":"204","unstructured":"Kabinet Ministriv Ukrainy, Rozporiadzhennia vid 17 lypnia 2019 r. \u2116 542-r \u201cPro skhvalennia Stratehi\u00ef reformuvannia derzhavnoho upravlinnia Ukrainy na 2019\u20132021 roky\u201d [Order of 17 July 2019 No. 542-r \"On Approval of the Strategy for Reforming Public Administration of Ukraine for 2019\u20132021\u201d] (Kyiv, 2019), https:\/\/zakon.rada.gov.ua\/laws\/show\/542-2019-%D1%80#Text."},{"key":"209","unstructured":"Ministerstvo Finansiv Ukrainy, National Revenue Strategy, Introduction."},{"key":"213","unstructured":"Swedish International Development Cooperation Agency (Sida), \u201cPublic Finance Management Support Programme for Ukraine (EU4PFM)\", OpenAid, Contribution No. SE-0-SE-6-11372, last modified 2020, https:\/\/openaid.se\/en\/contributions\/SE-0-SE-6-11372 (accessed 16 Sept. 2025)."},{"key":"216","unstructured":"EU4PFM, \u201cEU4PFM Prioritises Supporting Ukraine\u2019s Accession to the EU\", last modified 2024, https:\/\/eu4pfm.com.ua\/en\/eu4pfm-prioritises-supporting-ukraines-accession-to-the-eu\/ (accessed 16 Sept. 2025)."},{"key":"221","unstructured":"Sida, \u201cPublic Finance Management Support Programme\u201d."},{"key":"226","unstructured":"Derzhavna Podatkova Sluzhba Ukrainy, \u201cZavershen\u0456 Proekty (prohramy) m\u0456zhnarodnoi tekhn\u0456chno\u00ef dopomohy (MTD)\u201d [Finished International Technical Assistance Projects (Programs)], 2024, https:\/\/tax.gov.ua\/diyalnist-\/mijnarodne-\/proekti-programi-mtd\/647636.html."},{"key":"230","unstructured":"Lipsky, Street-Level Bureaucracy."},{"key":"236","unstructured":"Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD), \u201cTax Administrations Agree an Ambitious Set of Practical Initiatives to Support Digital Transformation, Enhance Tax Certainty and Deepen Partnerships on Global Tax Capacity Building\", news release, 11 Nov. 2024, https:\/\/www.oecd.org\/en\/about\/news\/announcements\/2024\/11\/tax-administrations-agree-an-ambitious-set-of-practical-initiatives-to-support-digital-transformation-enhance-tax-certainty-and-deepen-partnerships-on-global-tax-capacity-building.html (accessed 2 Nov. 2025)."},{"key":"243","unstructured":"Skatteverket, Skatteverkets strategiska riktning [The Swedish Tax Agency's strategic direction] (Stockholm: Skatteverket, 2024), 2, https:\/\/www.skatteverket.se\/download\/18.5b35a6251761e6914208c33\/1708608511972\/Skatteverkets%20strategiska%20riktning.pdf."},{"key":"249","unstructured":"Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD), Digital Transformation Maturity Model (2022), https:\/\/www.oecd.org\/tax\/forum-on-tax-administra tion\/publications-and-products\/digital-transformation-ma turity-model.htm (accessed 30 Oct. 2025)."},{"key":"262","unstructured":"Sweden, Skattef\u00f6rfarandelag (SFS 2011:1244) [Tax Procedure Act], 2011, sec. 2 (exempelparagraf), https:\/\/lagen.nu\/2011:1244#A6."},{"key":"268","unstructured":"Sweden, Offentlighets- och sekretesslag (SFS 2009:400) [Public Access to Information and Secrecy Act], 2009, sec. 3 (exempelparagraf), https:\/\/lagen.nu\/2009:400."},{"key":"276","unstructured":"Sweden, Tryckfrihetsf\u00f6rordningen (SFS 1949:105) [Freedom of the Press Act], 1949, chap. 2, sec. 1 (example section), https:\/\/www.riksdagen.se\/sv\/dokument-och-lagar\/dokument\/svensk-forfattningssamling\/tryckfrihetsforordning-1949105_sfs-1949-105\/."},{"key":"281","unstructured":"Swedish Authority for Privacy Protection (IMY), \u201cAbout Us\", https:\/\/www.imy.se\/en\/about-us\/ (accessed 21 Nov. 2025)."},{"key":"285","unstructured":"Skatteverket, \u201cProcessing of Personal Data\", https:\/\/www.skatteverket.se\/servicelankar\/otherlanguages\/englishengelska\/moreonskatteverket\/processingofpersonaldata.4.2106219b17988b0d2314bd.html (accessed 16 Sept. 2025)."},{"key":"293","unstructured":"Skatteverket, \u201cCivilberedskap\u201d [Civil preparedness], https:\/\/www.skatteverket.se\/omoss\/varverksamhet\/civilberedskap.4.48cfd212185efbb440b97ca.html (accessed 18 Sept. 2025)."},{"key":"296","unstructured":"Sweden, F\u00f6rordning om statliga myndigheters beredskap (SFS 2022:524) [Ordinance on State Authorities' Preparedness], 2022, appendix 1, https:\/\/www.riksdagen.se\/sv\/dokument-och-lagar\/dokument\/svensk-forfattningssamling\/forordning-2022524-om-statliga-myndigheters_sfs-2022-524\/#top."},{"key":"302","unstructured":"European Union, Regulation (EU) 2016\/679 of the European Parliament and of the Council of 27 April 2016 on the protection of natural persons with regard to the processing of personal data and on the free movement of such data (General Data Protection Regulation), Official Journal of the European Union, L 119, art. 5, https:\/\/eur-lex.europa.eu\/eli\/reg\/2016\/679\/oj."},{"key":"307","unstructured":"Sweden, Lag med kompletterande best\u00e4mmelser till EU:s dataskyddsf\u00f6rordning (SFS 2018:218) [Act with supplementary provisions to the EU General Data Protection Regulation], Svensk f\u00f6rfattningssamling, 2018, chap. 2, sec. 1, https:\/\/www.riksdagen.se\/sv\/dokument-och-lagar\/dokument\/svensk-forfattningssamling\/lag-2018218-med-kompletterande-bestammelser_sfs-2018-218\/."},{"key":"312","unstructured":"Sweden, F\u00f6rordning med kompletterande best\u00e4mmelser till EU:s dataskyddsf\u00f6rordning (SFS 2018:219) [Ordinance with supplementary provisions to the EU General Data Protection Regulation], Svensk f\u00f6rfattningssamling, 2018, sec. 3, https:\/\/www.riksdagen.se\/sv\/dokument-och-lagar\/dokument\/svensk-forfattningssamling\/forordning-2018219-med-kompletterande_sfs-2018-219\/."},{"key":"320","unstructured":"Sweden, Lag om behandling av personuppgifter i Skatteverkets folkbokf\u00f6ringsverksamhet (SFS 2001:182) [Legislation on the Swedish Tax Agency's processing of personal data in its population registration activities], Svensk f\u00f6rfattningssamling, 2001, chap. 2, sec. 1, https:\/\/www.riksdagen.se\/sv\/dokument-och-lagar\/dokument\/svensk-forfattningssamling\/lag-2001182-om-behandling-av-personuppgifter-i_sfs-2001-182\/."},{"key":"325","unstructured":"Sweden, F\u00f6rordning om behandling av personuppgifter i Skatteverkets folkbokf\u00f6ringsverksamhet (SFS 2001:589) [Ordinance on the Swedish Tax Agency's processing of personal data in its population registration activities], Svensk f\u00f6rfattningssamling, 2001, sec. 4, https:\/\/www.riksdagen.se\/sv\/dokument-och-lagar\/dokument\/svensk-forfattningssamling\/forordning-2001589-om-behandling-av_sfs-2001-589\/."},{"key":"331","unstructured":"European Commission, \u201cThe Data Act Explained\", https:\/\/digital-strategy.ec.europa.eu\/en\/factpages\/data-act-explained (accessed 21 Oct. 2025)."},{"key":"335","unstructured":"Verkhovna Rada Ukrainy, Pro informatsiiu (Zakon No. 2657-XII) [On Information (Law No. 2657-XII)], 1992, art. 16, https:\/\/zakon.rada.gov.ua\/laws\/show\/2657-12#Text."},{"key":"339","unstructured":"Verkhovna Rada Ukrainy, Podatkovyy kodeks Ukrainy (Zakon No. 2755-VI) [Tax Code of Ukraine (Law No. 2755-VI)], 2010, https:\/\/zakon.rada.gov.ua\/laws\/show\/2755-17#Text."},{"key":"344","unstructured":"Verkhovna Rada Ukrainy, Pro zakhyst personal\u02b9nykh danykh (Zakon No. 2297-VI) [On Personal Data Protection (Law No. 2297-VI)], 2010, https:\/\/zakon.rada.gov.ua\/laws\/show\/2297-17."},{"key":"348","unstructured":"Verkhovna Rada Ukrainy, Pro dostup do publichno\u00ef informatsi\u00ef (Zakon No. 2939-VI) [On Access to Public Information (Law No. 2939-VI)], 2011, https:\/\/zakon.rada.gov.ua\/laws\/show\/2939-17."},{"key":"353","unstructured":"Ibid., art. 6."},{"key":"356","unstructured":"Ukrainian Parliament Commissioner for Human Rights, \u201cPredstavnyky Upovnovazhenoho\u201d [Representatives of the Ombudsman], https:\/\/ombudsman.gov.ua\/uk\/predstavniki-upovnovazhenogo (accessed 5 Oct. 2025)."},{"key":"364","unstructured":"Sweden, Skattef\u00f6rfarandelag, chap. 10, sec. 1."},{"key":"368","unstructured":"Sweden, Lag om behandling av uppgifter i Skatteverkets beskattningsverksamhet (SFS 2001:181) [Act on the processing of data in the Swedish Tax Agency's taxation activities], Svensk f\u00f6rfattningssamling, 2001, chap. 2, sec. 1, https:\/\/www.riksdagen.se\/sv\/dokument-och-lagar\/dokument\/svensk-forfattningssamling\/lag-2001181-om-behandling-av-uppgifter-i_sfs-2001-181\/."},{"key":"374","unstructured":"Verkhovna Rada Ukrainy, Pro zakhyst personal\u02b9nykh danykh, art. 2, 5."},{"key":"381","unstructured":"European Commission, New European Interoperability Framework: Promoting seamless services and data flows for European public administrations (Brochure) (Luxembourg: Publications Office of the European Union, 2017), 37, https:\/\/ec.europa.eu\/isa2\/sites\/default\/files\/eif_brochure_final.pdf."},{"key":"386","unstructured":"Ibid., 40."},{"key":"388","unstructured":"OECD, Going Digital, 22."},{"key":"392","doi-asserted-by":"publisher","DOI":"10.1787\/53b8dade-en"},{"key":"397","unstructured":"Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD), Tax Administration 3.0 \u2013 Action Plan Update (Paris: OECD, 2022), 11, https:\/\/www.oecd.org\/tax\/forum-on-tax-administration\/publications-and-products\/tax-administration-3-0-action-plan-update.pdf."},{"key":"401","unstructured":"OECD, Tax Administration 3.0, 3."},{"key":"405","unstructured":"OECD, Going Digital, 22."},{"key":"409","unstructured":"Ibid., 25."},{"key":"411","unstructured":"OECD, Tax Administration 3.0 and Natural Systems, 12."},{"key":"419","unstructured":"OECD, Tax Administration Digitalisation, 39."},{"key":"424","unstructured":"Ibid."},{"key":"429","unstructured":"AI Tax Administration, \u201cSweden AI Country Report\", https:\/\/taxadmin.ai\/country\/sweden-ai-country-report\/ (accessed 9 Oct. 2025)."},{"key":"432","unstructured":"Skatteverket, \u201cS\u00e5 arbetar Skatteverket med AI\u201d [How the Swedish Tax Agency works with AI], https:\/\/www.skatteverket.se\/omoss\/varverksamhet\/fragorskatteverketarbetarmed\/aiartificiellintelligens.4.1997e70d1848dabbac9363f.html (accessed 29 Sept. 2025)."},{"key":"435","unstructured":"Skatteverket, \u201cSkatteverkets arbete med AI\u201d [The Swedish Tax Agency's work with AI], https:\/\/www.skatteverket.se\/omoss\/jobbahososs\/jobbamedithososs\/skatteverketsarbetemedai.4.13948c0e18e810bfa0c6d0c.html (accessed 29 Sept. 2025)."},{"key":"441","unstructured":"AI Tax Administration, \u201cSweden AI Country Report\u201d."},{"key":"446","unstructured":"EIPA, \u201cAutomated Artificial Intelligence and Machine Learning Supported Tax Registration for Non-Swedish Customers\", https:\/\/www.eipa.eu\/epsa\/automated-artificial-intelligence-and-machine-learning-supported-tax-registration-for-non-swedish-customers\/ (accessed 29 Sept. 2025)."},{"key":"451","unstructured":"OECD, Tax Administration 3.0, 36."},{"key":"454","unstructured":"OECD, Tax Administration Digitalisation, 22."},{"key":"460","unstructured":"A. Kubaszewska, \u201cArtificial Intelligence and Automated Decision Making Systems Adoption by the Public Sector: Insights from AI and ADM Projects by the Swedish Public Sector Organisations\u201d (Master's thesis, Hertie School, 2024), 22."},{"key":"462","unstructured":"Ibid., 28."},{"key":"468","unstructured":"Ibid., 23."},{"key":"473","unstructured":"Ibid."},{"key":"478","unstructured":"Ibid., 28."},{"key":"484","unstructured":"Derzhavna podatkova sluzhba Ukrainy, \u201cPokrokova videoinstruktsiia pro protses prokhodzhennia podatkovykh nakladnykh u systemi SMKOR: Ruslan Kravchenko poiasnyv pravyla roboty\u201d [Step-by-step video instruction on the process of passing tax invoices in the SMKOR system: Ruslan Kravchenko explained the rules of work], https:\/\/tax.gov.ua\/media-tsentr\/novini\/863572.html (accessed 10 Oct. 2025)."},{"key":"487","unstructured":"LIGA ZAKON, \u201cIak oskarzhyty vkliuchennia kompani\u00ef do pereliku ryzykovykh platnykiv?\u201d [How to appeal the inclusion of a company in the list of risky taxpayers?], 19 Nov. 2021, https:\/\/biz.ligazakon.net\/analitycs\/207617_yak-oskarzhiti-vklyuchennya-kompan-do-perelku-rizikovikh-platnik."},{"key":"491","unstructured":"Kabinet Ministriv Ukrainy, \u201cIevhen Ole\u012dnikov: SMKOR \u2013 tse dzherelo potuzhno\u00ef analitychno\u00ef informatsi\u00ef\u201d [Yevhen Oleynikov: SMKOOR is a source of powerful analytical information], 14 July 2020, https:\/\/www.kmu.gov.ua\/news\/yevgen-olejnikov-smkor-ce-dzherelo-potuzhnoyi-analitichnoyi-informaciyi."},{"key":"495","unstructured":"Discussed in more detail in V. Tsymbal, \u201cWhat\u2019s under the Hood of \u2018Tax in a Smartphone\u2019?: A Comparative Legal Analysis in Light of the Ukrainian Experience\", International Tax Studies (ITAXS) 10 (2024): 9."},{"key":"498","unstructured":"The National Revenue Strategy references an assessment of the State Tax Service (STS) using the TADAT methodology, specifically citing the 2018 report. Notably, this assessment identified several structural shortcomings: the unstructured nature of the tax risk assessment process applied by the former State Fiscal Service (SFS) at the time of the evaluation, which was conducted annually at the level of separate functional departments rather than comprehensively; the absence of a multi-year strategic document covering the entire scope of tax risk assessment; the fragmentation of the current risk management process across several executive-approved documents, with compliance being monitored individually and ad hoc; and the lack of an annual plan for improving tax compliance that would address all risks of non-compliance with tax legislation and provide operational steps for mitigation, among many others. See Ministerstvo Finansiv Ukrainy, Natsional\u02b9na stratehiya dokhodiv do 2030 roku [National Revenue Strategy until 2030] (Kyiv, 2023), 24, https:\/\/mof.gov.ua\/storage\/files\/National%20Revenue%20Strategy_2030_.pdf."},{"key":"504","unstructured":"Rada biznes-ombudsmena, \u201cSMKOR iak instrument administruvannia PDV\u201d [SMCOR as a VAT administration tool], https:\/\/boi.org.ua\/reports-post\/smkor-yak-instrument-administruvannya-pdv\/ (accessed 11 Sept. 2025)."},{"key":"508","unstructured":"Kabinet Ministriv Ukrainy, Pro zatverdzhennia poriadkiv z pytan zupynennia reiestratsii podatkovo\u00ef nakladnoi \/ rozrakhunku koryhuvannia v Yedynomu reiestri podatkovykh nakladnykh (Postanova No. 1165) [On approval of the procedures regarding the suspension of registration of a tax invoice \/ adjustment calculation in the Unified Register of Tax Invoices (Decree No. 1165)], 2019, https:\/\/tax.gov.ua\/zakonodavstvo\/podatkove-zakonodavstvo\/postanovi-kabinetu-ministr\/75417.html."},{"key":"512","unstructured":"KPMG International, \u201cIak oskarzhyty vkliuchennia kompani\u00ef do pereliku ryzykovykh platnykiv?\u201d [How to appeal the inclusion of a company in the list of risky taxpayers?], 19 Nov. 2021, https:\/\/kpmg.com\/ua\/uk\/home\/insights\/2021\/11\/yak-oskarzhyty-vklyuchennya-kompaniyi-do-pereliku-ryzykovykh-platnykiv.html."},{"key":"516","unstructured":"Ibid."},{"key":"520","unstructured":"Derzhavna podatkova sluzhba Ukrainy, \u201cDPS proponuie biznesu doluchytysia do obhovorennia zmin shchodo udoskonalennia systemy SMKOR\u201d [DTS proposes business to join the discussion of changes to improve the SMKOOR system], 7 July 2025, https:\/\/tax.gov.ua\/media-tsentr\/novini\/912614.html."},{"key":"525","unstructured":"Accounting Chamber of Ukraine, \u0417\u0432\u0456\u0442 \u043f\u0440\u043e \u0440\u0435\u0437\u0443\u043b\u044c\u0442\u0430\u0442\u0438 \u0430\u0443\u0434\u0438\u0442\u0443 \u0435\u0444\u0435\u043a\u0442\u0438\u0432\u043d\u043e\u0441\u0442\u0456 \u043d\u0430 \u0442\u0435\u043c\u0443 \u00ab\u041e\u0441\u043a\u0430\u0440\u0436\u0435\u043d\u043d\u044f \u0440\u0456\u0448\u0435\u043d\u044c \u0414\u041f\u0421: \u0432\u043f\u043b\u0438\u0432 \u043d\u0430 \u0435\u043a\u043e\u043d\u043e\u043c\u0456\u0447\u043d\u0443 \u0430\u043a\u0442\u0438\u0432\u043d\u0456\u0441\u0442\u044c \u043f\u043b\u0430\u0442\u043d\u0438\u043a\u0456\u0432 \u043f\u043e\u0434\u0430\u0442\u043a\u0456\u0432\u00bb [Report on the results of the effectiveness audit on the topic \"Appeal of SFS Decisions: Impact on the Economic Activity of Taxpayers\u201d], 2024, 12 (example page), https:\/\/rp.gov.ua\/upload-files\/Activity\/Collegium\/2024\/49-1_2024\/Zvit_49-1_2024.pdf."},{"key":"530","unstructured":"Derzhavna podatkova sluzhba Ukrainy, \u201cDPS proponuie biznesu doluchytysia do obhovorennia zmin shchodo udoskonalennia systemy SMKOR\u201d [DTS proposes business to join the discussion of changes to improve the SMKOR system], 7 July 2025, https:\/\/tax.gov.ua\/media-tsentr\/novini\/912614.html."},{"key":"533","unstructured":"Derzhavna podatkova sluzhba Ukrainy, \u201cZ 27 veresnia zminyuiutsia pravyla reiestratsi\u00ef podatkovykh nakladnykh\u201d [Rules for the registration of tax invoices change from September 27], 25 Sept. 2025, https:\/\/tax.gov.ua\/media-tsentr\/novini\/940251.html."},{"key":"537","unstructured":"EU4PFM (EU Public Finance Management Support Programme for Ukraine), \u201cTaxes\", https:\/\/eu4pfm.com.ua\/en\/dosiahnuti-rezultaty\/podatky\/ (accessed 21 Nov. 2025)."},{"key":"540","unstructured":"Derzhavna podatkova sluzhba Ukrainy, \u201cShche odyn krok do efektyvnosti ta prozorosti: DPS vprovadzheno IT-systemu dlia administratyvnoho ta sudovoho oskarzhennia\u201d [Another step towards efficiency and transparency: The STS has implemented an IT system for administrative and judicial appeal], 21 July 2023, https:\/\/tax.gov.ua\/media-tsentr\/novini\/693291.html."},{"key":"545","unstructured":"Derzhavna podatkova sluzhba Ukrainy, \u201cRozpochav robotu elektronnyy servis \u00abInfoTAX\u00bb\u201d [The \"InfoTAX\" electronic service has started operating], 6 Nov. 2020, https:\/\/tax.gov.ua\/media-tsentr\/novini\/440210.html."},{"key":"550","unstructured":"Derzhavna podatkova sluzhba Ukrainy, \u201cTo the Attention of Single Tax Payers (Legal Entities)!\", 8 Jan. 2025, https:\/\/tax.gov.ua\/en\/new-about-taxes--hotlines-\/858059.html."},{"key":"556","unstructured":"Derzhavna podatkova sluzhba Ukrainy, \u201cRozpochav robotu elektronnyy servis\u201d."},{"key":"562","unstructured":"Derzhavna podatkova sluzhba Ukrainy, \u201cElektronnyy kabinet platnyka podatkiv \u2014 zruchna al\u02b9ternatyva vizytam do podatkovo\u00ef\u201d [Taxpayer's electronic cabinet is a convenient alternative to tax office visits], 23 Oct. 2025, https:\/\/rv.tax.gov.ua\/media-ark\/local-news\/945874.html."},{"key":"577","unstructured":"Ministerstvo tsyfrovoi transformatsii Ukrainy. \u201cWINWIN: Ukraina zatverdyla Stratehiiu tsyfrovoho rozvytku innovatsii do 2030 roku\u201d [WINWIN: Ukraine approved the Digital Development Strategy for Innovation until 2030], 14 Jan. 2025, http:\/\/thedigital.gov.ua\/news\/technologies\/winwin-ukraina-zatverdila-strategiyu-tsifrovogo-rozvitku-innovatsiy-do-2030-roku."},{"key":"580","unstructured":"The Digital Innovation Development Strategy until 2030 was created at the initiative of the Ministry of Digital Transformation of Ukraine in cooperation with the Ministry of Education and Science of Ukraine and the Office of Effective Regulation BRDO, with the support of the USAID Project \"Cybersecurity of Critical Infrastructure of Ukraine\". Sectoral strategies are structured with the support of the Good Governance Fund project \"Innovation Ecosystem\", funded by UK International Development. See ibid."},{"key":"585","unstructured":"Ministerstvo tsyfrovoi transformatsii Ukrainy, \u201cWorld's First National AI Assistant? Ukraine Just Launched It. Powered by Gemini\", 29 Sept. 2025, https:\/\/digitalstate.gov.ua\/news\/tech\/diiaai-pratsiuye-na-tekhnolohiyi-gemini-35-tysiach-ukrayintsiv-vze-skorystalysia-novym-derzavnym-ai-servisom."},{"key":"589","unstructured":"\"Diia\u00a0\u2014 the flagship product of\u00a0Ukraine\u2019s Ministry of\u00a0Digital Transformation that has made digitalization a\u00a0part of\u00a0pop culture. It\u00a0is\u00a0an\u00a0ecosystem that integrates government services and digital documents into a\u00a0smartphone, making interaction with the state simple and convenient\". See Ministerstvo tsyfrovoi transformatsii Ukrainy, \u201cDiia\u201d [Diia], https:\/\/digitalstate.gov.ua\/projects\/govtech\/diia (accessed 5 Nov. 2025)."},{"key":"597","unstructured":"Ministerstvo tsyfrovo\u00ef transformatsi\u00ef Ukrainy, \u201cWorld's First National AI Assistant\u201d."},{"key":"601","unstructured":"DOU, \u201cV \u00abDi\u00ef\u00bb zapustyly chat-bota zi shtuchnym intelektom. Shcho vin vmiie\u201d [An artificial intelligence chatbot was launched in \"Diia\". What it can do], 1 Sept. 2025, https:\/\/dou.ua\/lenta\/news\/ministry-of-digital-transformation-launched-diia-ai\/."},{"key":"610","unstructured":"Information System Authority (RIA), \u201cThe Vision of B\u00fcrokratt\", accessed 21 Nov. 2025, https:\/\/www.ria.ee\/en\/state-information-system\/personal-services\/burokratt."},{"key":"623","unstructured":"A. Raieste, P. Ojamaa and M. Solvak, Personal Government\u2014A Vision for a Postdigital Era of Equitable and Sustainable Public Services (Tartu: Nortal and University of Tartu, 2023), 4, https:\/\/dfr.oregon.gov\/business\/licensing\/insurance\/Documents\/2139.pdf."},{"key":"630","unstructured":"Ibid., 27."},{"key":"634","unstructured":"Ibid."},{"key":"638","unstructured":"DOU, \u201cV \u00abDi\u00ef\u00bb zapustyly chat-bota\u201d."},{"key":"642","unstructured":"Ministerstvo tsyfrovo\u00ef transformatsi\u00ef Ukrainy, \u201cWorld's First National AI Assistant\u201d."},{"key":"649","unstructured":"Derzhavna podatkova sluzhba Ukrainy, \u201cOfisy podatkovykh konsul\u02b9tantiv: u DPS rozpovily z yakymy pytanniamy naychastishe zvertayut\u02b9sia platnyky\u201d [Tax consultant offices: The STS told which issues taxpayers address most often], 25 Sept. 2025, https:\/\/tax.gov.ua\/media-tsentr\/novini\/937350.html."},{"key":"653","unstructured":"Statens servicecenter, \u201c\u00d6rebro Service Centre\", https:\/\/www.statenssc.se\/en\/visit-a-service-centre\/orebro-service-centre (accessed 3 Nov. 2025)."},{"key":"661","unstructured":"M. M. Groothuis and J. S. Svensson, \u201cExpert System Support and Juridical Quality\", in Legal Knowledge and Information Systems. Jurix 2000: The Thirteenth Annual Conference, edited by J. Breuker, R. Leeens and R. Winkels (IOS Press, 2000), cited in Bovens and Zouridis, \u201cStreet-Level to System-Level Bureaucracies\", 180."},{"key":"664","doi-asserted-by":"publisher","DOI":"10.2139\/ssrn.4573321"},{"key":"667","unstructured":"R. Crootof, M. E. Kaminski and W. N. Price II, \u201cHumans in the Loop\", Vanderbilt Law Review 76, no. 2 (2023), cited in European Data Protection Supervisor (EDPS), \u201cTechDispatch 2\/2025: Human Oversight in Automated Decision-Making\", 23 Sept. 2025, https:\/\/www.edps.europa.eu\/data-protection\/our-work\/publications\/techdispatch\/2025-09-23-techdispatch-22025-human-oversight-automated-making_en."},{"key":"672","unstructured":"Raieste, Ojamaa and Solvak, Personal Government, 27."},{"key":"676","unstructured":"Ibid., 41."},{"key":"679","unstructured":"OECD, Tax Administration 3.0, 7."},{"key":"684","unstructured":"IBM, \u201cWhat is Industry 4.0?\u201d."},{"key":"688","unstructured":"University of Greater Manchester, \u201cThe Cambridge Analytica Scandal and What It Teaches Us\", 19 April 2021, https:\/\/greatermanchester.ac.uk\/blogs\/the-cambridge-analytica-scandal-and-what-it-teaches-us."},{"key":"692","unstructured":"OECD, Tax Administration 3.0, 71."},{"key":"697","doi-asserted-by":"publisher","DOI":"10.1177\/2053951718820549"},{"key":"701","unstructured":"A. Larson, \u201cNeoliberalism\", EBSCO Research Starters, 2025, https:\/\/www.ebsco.com\/research-starters\/diplomacy-and-international-relations\/neoliberalism."},{"key":"707","doi-asserted-by":"publisher","DOI":"10.1111\/puar.13293"},{"key":"712","unstructured":"Bovens and Zouridis, \u201cStreet-Level to System-Level Bureaucracies\", 182."},{"key":"715","unstructured":"H. A. Oldenziel, Wetgeving en rechtszekerheid: Een onderzoek naar de bijdrage van het legaliteitsvereiste aan de rechtszekerheid van de burger [Legislation and legal certainty: An investigation into the contribution of the legality requirement to the legal certainty of the citizen] (Deventer, 1998), 45 cited at ibid."},{"key":"720","doi-asserted-by":"publisher","DOI":"10.4337\/9781803928562.00047"},{"key":"724","unstructured":"Larsson et al., \u201cFour Facets of AI Transparency\", 4."},{"key":"731","unstructured":"Larsson et al., \u201cFour Facets of AI Transparency\", 8."},{"key":"734","unstructured":"B. Meyer, \u201cGetting a Program Right, in Nine Episodes\", Bertrand Meyer's technology+ blog, 26 March 2020, https:\/\/bertrandmeyer.com\/2020\/03\/26\/getting-program-right-nine-episodes\/."},{"key":"739","unstructured":"Larsson et al., \u201cFour Facets of AI Transparency\", 5."},{"key":"745","unstructured":"OECD, Tax Administration 3.0, 48."},{"key":"750","unstructured":"OECD, Tax Administration 3.0, 11."},{"key":"770","unstructured":"OECD, Going Digital, 28."},{"key":"777","doi-asserted-by":"crossref","unstructured":"S. Strau\u00df, \u201c\u201cDon\u2019t Let Me Be Misunderstood\u201d Critical AI Literacy for the Constructive Use of AI Technology\", TATuP-Zeitschrift f\u00fcr Technikfolgenabsch\u00e4tzung in Theorie und Praxis 30, no. 3 (2021): 45, https:\/\/dfr.oregon.gov\/pages\/index.aspx, cited at Larsson et al., \u201cFour Facets of AI Transparency\", 5.","DOI":"10.14512\/tatup.30.3.44"}],"container-title":["International Tax Studies"],"original-title":[],"language":"en","link":[{"URL":"https:\/\/research.ibfd.org\/document\/itaxs_2026_11_int_1","content-type":"unspecified","content-version":"vor","intended-application":"similarity-checking"}],"deposited":{"date-parts":[[2026,11,11]],"date-time":"2026-11-11T19:45:22Z","timestamp":1794426322000},"score":1,"resource":{"primary":{"URL":"https:\/\/www.ibfd.org\/doi\/302fw4w"}},"subtitle":[],"short-title":[],"issued":{"date-parts":[[2026,11,4]]},"references-count":155,"journal-issue":{"issue":"11","published-print":{"date-parts":[[2026,11,4]]}},"URL":"https:\/\/doi.org\/10.59403\/302fw4w","relation":{},"ISSN":["2590-1117"],"issn-type":[{"value":"2590-1117","type":"electronic"}],"subject":[],"published":{"date-parts":[[2026,11,4]]}}}